Almost all pre 1858 wills were destroyed in Dublin in 1922 and generally, only indexes survive; however surviving wills devised by residents of Donagheady can be found in the Wills section of this website http://www.cotyroneireland.com/menus/wills.html
This is an old submission, forwarded by a kind researcher many years ago, but unfortunately lacks a source except that it was transcribed from a document held in PRONI, Belfast.
The original spelling of the parish was Donakiddy.
| SURNAME | GIVEN NAME | TOWNLAND | PROBATED |
| ACHESON | Michael | Cloughole [Cloghogle] | 1840 |
| ALEXANDER | Joseph | Maghereagh | 1781 |
| ALLAN | David | Cloughboy | 1734 |
| ALLAN |
James Joseph David |
Cloughboy | 1731 |
| ALLAN | Joseph | Cloughboy | 1749 |
| ALLAN | Thomas | Cloughboy | 1740 |
| BROWN | Alexander | Altreste | 1847 |
| BROWN | Alexander | Donagheady | 1753 |
| BROWN | Andrew | Altreste | 1855 |
| BROWN | Hugh | Grange | 1784 |
| BROWN | John | Altreste | 1790 |
| BROWN | Joseph | Aughafad | 1780 |
| BROWN | Patrick | Grange | 1785 |
| CURRISTAN [McCURRISTON] | John | Cloughboy | 1817 |
| DAVISON | James | Gortivea | 1775 |
| DIVINE | Henry | Belaghs [Balix?] | 1821 |
| DUNN | Andrew | Glenagoorland | 1838 |
| DUNN | Catherine | Dullerton | 1852 |
| DUNN | Charles | Glenagoorland | 1811 |
| DUNN | Robert | Cullion | 1747 |
| ELLIOTT | Daniel | Tamnakeery | 1735 |
| ELLIOTT | William | Tamnakeery | 1775 |
| ELLIS | Robert | Lisdivin | 1816 |
| EWIN | John | Donagheady | 1762 |
| FULTON | John | Stranabrosney | 1770 |
| GRAHAM | James | Lisnarrow | 1825 |
| HALL | John | Collermoney | 1751 |
| HALL | Robert | Culmaghery | 1740 |
| HALL | Robert | Tully | 1797 |
| HAMILL | Rev. Hugh | Drumeny | 1804 |
| HAMILTON | Catherine | Tirkernaghan | 1741 |
| HAMILTON | Gustavus | Binelly | 1805 |
| HAMILTON | Hugh | Donagheady | 1689 |
| HAMILTON | James | Castlemellan | 1805 |
| HAMILTON | James | Drumeny | 1734 |
| HAMILTON | James | Magheramason | 1734 |
| HAMILTON | James | Magheramason | 1775 |
| HAMILTON | John | Castlemellan | 1757 |
| HAMILTON | John | Drumeny | 1745 |
| HAMILTON | Michael | Gortavea | 1816 |
| HAMILTON | Rev. John | [?] | 1689 |
| HAMILTON | Rev. Patrick | Donagheady | 1635 |
| HAMILTON | Thomas | Gortavea | 1763 |
| HAMILTON | Thomas | Magheramason | 1754 |
| HASTY | William | Greystone | 1751 |
| HOLMES | Rev John | Brosney [Stranabrosney] | 1832 |
| JACK | Daniel | Lisnar? [Lisnarrow?] | 1771 |
| KEE | William | Gortileck | 1783 |
| KERR | Robert | Drumeny | 1828 |
| KILGOWRE [KILGORE] | John | Donagheady | 1693 |
| KNOX | George | Ballyskeagh | 1806 |
| KNOX | Margaret | Drummony | 1819 |
| LAUGHLIN | William | Ballaghlair | 1829 |
| LAUGHLIN | William | Donagheady | 1744 |
| LAUGHLIN | William | Gortileck | 1779 |
| LEIGHTON | James | Craigateen [Carrickatane] | 1713 |
| LESLIE | John | Tullyard | 1819 |
| LOGUE | Patrick | Drummon | 1843 |
| LOVE | David | Clare | 1744 |
| LOVE | David | Cloughboy | 1773 |
| LOVE | David | Tamnaclare | 1783 |
| LOVE | Elizabeth | Menaghill | 1781 |
| LOVE | Robert | Donagheady | 1812 |
| LOVE | Victor | Creaghcor | 1777 |
| LOWRY | William | Fawney | 1801 |
| MACKLIM | James | Ardcame | 1807 |
| MARTIN | John | Killycurry | 1771 |
| MARTIN | Robert | Gortmonly | 1763 |
| MATHERS | John | Donagheady | 1629 |
| MATHEWS | William | Donemana | 1798 |
| MAXWELL | William | Tirkernaghan | 1780 |
| McCLURE | John | Tamnakeery | 1770 |
| McCOART | William | Cullion | 1829 |
| McCONNELL | Edward | Cullion | 1825 |
| McCORMICK | Frederick | Burndennett | 1842 |
| McCREA | Alexander | Drumgauty | 1807 |
| McCREA | James | Gobnascale | 1829 |
| McCREA | John | Glencush | 1691 |
| McCREA | Robert | Upper Bennelly | 1842 |
| McCREA | Samuel | Tullyard | 1856 |
| McCREA | William | Cooley | 1715 |
| McCULLOGH | William | Tamnabready | 1749 |
| McELHENNY | James | Cloghogle | 1849 |
| McELHENNY | Nancy | Lisdivin | 1757 |
| McFARLAND | Duncan | Lochash | 1695 |
| McGEE | Robert | Magheramason | 1814 |
| McINTYRE | Andrew | Maghereagh | 1777 |
| McINTYRE | John | Maghereagh | 1743 |
| McINTYRE | John | Maghereagh | 1791 |
| McKEEVER | Henry | Sollus | 1770 |
| McKEEVER | Henry | Sollus | 1773 |
| McMORRIS | James | Ardmore | 1744 |
| McMORRIS | James | Ardmore | 1804 |
| McMORRIS | Joseph | Tullyard | 1804 |
| McMORRISH | Patrick | Altmore | 1705 |
| McNEELY | Samuel | Magheramason | 1813 |
| MITCHELL | Alexander | Letrim | 1721 |
| MITCHELL | David | Glencosh | 1640 |
| MOODY | John | Coolmaghery | 1788 |
| NESBITT | William | Cloghogle | 1838 |
| NIXON | John | Castlewarren | 1835 |
| NIXON | Thomas | Castlewarren | 1740 |
| POLLOCK | George | Castlewarren | 1799 |
| RAMSAY | John | Faney [Fawney] | 1813 |
| RAMSAY | Thomas | Gobnaskeal [Gobnascale] | 1793 |
| ROBERTSON | James | Moneykenan [Moneycannon] | 1764 |
| ROBINSON | Andrew | Tavnabready | 1809 |
| RODGERS | Moses | Cavnacaw | 1854 |
| RUSSEL | James | Lisnarrow | 1818 |
| SIMPSON | James | Creaghorr | 1777 |
| SMITH | Robert | Belnamalaught [Ballynamallaght] | 1848 |
| SMITH | Sarah | Belnamalaught | 1807 |
| STEWART | James | Altreste | 1832 |
| STEWART | James | Belesceagh [Ballyskeagh, Leckpatrick?] | 1732 |
| TAGGART | Joseph | Maghereagh | 1807 |
| THOMPSON | James | Cloghogle | 1753 |
| THOMPSON | John | Loughneas | 1725 |
| WALKER | John | Donagheady | 1750 |
| WENSLEY | Letitia | Prospect | 1788 |
| WENSLEY | Rev. Thomas | Sandville | 1737 |
| WILSON | Claud | Donagheady | 1636 |
| WOODS | Andrew, Gent | Artdcome [Ardcame] | 1773 |
| WOODS | Mary | Artcome [Ardcame] | 1836 |
| WOODS | Robert | Artcome [Ardcame] | 1791 |
| YOUNG | Archibald | Donagheady | 1638 |